New City Holiday Ice Cream Pies (PRE-ORDER)

Holiday Ice Cream Pie Pre-Orders are Open! The holiday season is here and we wanted to bring nostalgic holiday flavors to life in ice cream form! Each pie is handmade with love in Shirley, MA by our dedicated team and features our signature ice cream, seasonal ingredients, and a handmade, buttery graham cracker and waffle cone crust.

Pre-orders are live December 1st through December 19th

Pick-ups available December 22nd through December 24th

We have three incredible holiday pies:

Peppermint Stick: Jingle all the way to the holidays with our Peppermint Stick pie! It's a delicious blend of sweet cream ice cream and crushed peppermint candies, in a graham cracker and waffle cone crust. Topped with our homemade whipped cream, it's a combination of winter flavors that's just mint to be! One bite and you'll be dashing through the snow for more.

Apple Crisp: Savor the taste of the season with our Apple Crisp pie! This dessert brings together the warmth of roasted apples, cinnamon sugar, and the comforting crunch of crispy oat streusel, all nestled in a graham cracker and waffle cone crust. Topped with whipped cream, this pie is guaranteed to warm your taste buds on even the chilliest of winter days!

Turtle Pecan Pie: Satisfy your sweet tooth with our Turtle Pecan pie! Dive into a world of molasses and brown sugar ice cream, mingling with candied pecans and milk chocolate, all resting in a graham cracker and waffle cone crust and topped with whipped cream. This pie is a 'nutty' delight that promises to whisk you away to a winter wonderland!

PICK UP is available starting on12/22-12/24 IN STORE ONLY. Please indicate Sudbury, Hudson, Cambridge, or Arlington pick-up when choosing your tickets.

Any questions about pick-up time, allergens or general inquiries can be sent directly to aW5mbyB8IG5ld2NpdHltaWNyb2NyZWFtZXJ5ICEgY29t