Murder Mystery Dinner

Mama Mia Mayhem: "Blood Relatives"

$80 per person. Reservations required; space is limited.
Call 814-676-1733.
https://octrr.org/special-events-tours/murder-mystery-dinners/

Join your favorite big, fat, Italian clan, the Stromboli Family, as they gather for a memorial service to bid farewell to their beloved matriarch Mama Filomena, who has finally taken off to that big pizza parlor in the sky (this time by natural causes…). Their usual raucous rivalry to inherit the family business is finally at an end – – or is it??

Mystery guests and secrets from the past abound as the family that ‘preys’ together, tries to stay together… until one of those loaded cannoli hits its mark! Once again, murder shows its ugly face in the Stromboli family portrait! Match your wits against the witless and try to solve tonight’s whacking — er, murder, before the spaghetti sauce hits the fan — again!

Your evening begins at 4:45 PM at Perry Street Station (409 S. Perry St., Titusville, PA) with dinner (caterer TBD). The performance by In All Seriousness then moves onboard the train for the main acts of the show. The train departs at 6:15 PM and returns to the station around 9:00 PM. Dessert will be served during the final reveal, and prizes will be awarded to those who correctly guess “whodunit!”

You may also like the following events from Oil Creek and Titusville Railroad:

• This April, 4th April, 01:00 pm, Peter Cottontail Express in Titusville
• This May, 6th May, 11:00 am, Spring 2026 Heritage School Tours in Titusville
• This May, 9th May, 04:45 pm, Murder Mystery Dinner in Titusville