The Forgotten Carols Musical, 12/5/25 at 7:30pm in PAYSON

The Forgotten Carols Musical features breathtaking performances of heartwarming melodies and laugh-out-loud entertainment within a timeless Christmas story. Hear your favorite songs, like “Homeless,” from Michael McLean’s original hit album, sung by incredible musical theater performers. Immerse yourself in the magic of the holiday season as you witness the story of the Forgotten Carols coming to life on stage. Don't miss out on this incredible in-person event that will leave you feeling uplifted and filled with joy. 

Join us Friday evening @ 7:30pm in the auditorium of the new Payson High School.

Show Synopsis

The Forgotten Carols musical theater stage performance tells the story of Connie Lou, a nurse whose empty life is changed when John, a new patient she is attending, recounts the story of Christ’s birth as told by little known characters in the nativity story. The accounts from the Innkeeper, the Shepherd and others help the nurse discover what the world has forgotten about Christmas, ultimately encouraging her to open her heart to the joy of this special season.

Above: Kyle Olsen sings "Homeless" alongside an amazing quartet of singers

Below: Adrien Swenson,  as Nurse "Connie Lou" Chamberlain

Also check out other Entertainment events in Payson.